Losing an experienced employee creates more than a vacancy. Understanding why they left could help prevent the next one.
When someone resigns, the immediate priority is usually obvious.
We need to replace them.
The job description is reviewed. The salary is agreed. The vacancy goes to market.
But there is another question that is often overlooked:
Why did they leave in the first place?
Not every resignation is preventable. People move for different reasons, and sometimes leaving is simply the right career decision.
But when an organisation repeatedly loses people from the same team, function or level, recruitment may not be the real problem.
The vacancy could be a symptom of something else.
The replacement cycle
Imagine an experienced employee leaves.
The organisation recruits a replacement.
The new employee joins, but six or twelve months later they leave too.
The role goes back to market.
Another person is appointed.
And the cycle continues.
At some point, employers need to stop asking:
“Where can we find another candidate?”
and start asking:
“Why do people keep leaving this role?”
That distinction can save considerable time, cost and management effort.
Salary matters, but it isn’t the whole picture
Salary will always be an important consideration.
If an employee’s pay has fallen significantly behind the market, that can understandably influence their decision to move.
But employees rarely make career decisions based on salary alone.
Other factors can include:
- Lack of progression
- Poor management
- Excessive workload
- Limited flexibility
- Lack of recognition
- Unclear expectations
- Lack of development
- Poor communication
- Lack of trust
- Changes within the organisation
- Feeling that their contribution is no longer valued
The important point is not that one factor is more important than another.
It is that employers need to understand what is happening within their own organisation.
Look for patterns
One resignation may not tell you very much.
Patterns can.
If several experienced employees leave within a short period, ask why.
If new starters leave within their first year, examine the recruitment, onboarding and management experience.
If people consistently leave one particular team, look at workload, leadership and team dynamics.
If experienced employees are moving to similar roles elsewhere, review salary, progression and the overall employee proposition.
The most useful information may be in the pattern rather than the individual resignation.
Exit interviews are useful, but they aren’t enough
Exit interviews can provide valuable information.
But by the time someone is sitting in an exit interview, they have already made their decision.
Organisations therefore need to create opportunities for honest conversations before resignation becomes the outcome.
Managers can ask:
What would make your role better over the next 12 months?
Is anything preventing you from doing your best work?
Do you see a future for yourself here?
What skills would you like to develop?
Is your workload sustainable?
What would make you consider leaving?
The answers won’t always be comfortable.
But useful information is only valuable if the organisation is prepared to act on it.
Retention doesn’t mean keeping everyone
A good retention strategy does not mean trying to prevent every employee from leaving.
People will move.
Careers develop. Circumstances change. Organisations change.
The objective is to understand which people and capabilities are critical to retain, and why.
Consider where you have:
- Hard-to-replace specialist knowledge
- Critical client relationships
- Experienced managers
- Future leaders
- Technical expertise
- Business-critical organisational knowledge
These are the employees where unexpected turnover can have the greatest impact.
What happens when experience walks out of the door?
Replacing someone involves more than recruitment costs.
There can also be:
- Lost productivity
- Management time
- Pressure on colleagues
- Lost organisational knowledge
- Delayed projects
- Customer disruption
- Training and onboarding time
- Further recruitment costs if the replacement doesn’t work out
For specialist and senior roles, the impact can be particularly significant.
This is why retention and recruitment should not be treated as completely separate strategies.
Your recruitment process can provide market intelligence
The recruitment process itself can tell employers something about their organisation.
If candidates consistently question the same aspects of a role, listen.
If people are reluctant to accept because of salary, flexibility or progression, the market may be telling you something.
If candidates withdraw after learning more about the working environment or management structure, that is worth understanding.
Recruitment is not just about finding candidates.
It can also provide valuable market intelligence.
Before replacing the person, review the role
When someone leaves, take the opportunity to ask whether the role is still right for the organisation.
Ask:
Is this still the role we need?
Perhaps the business has changed.
Perhaps some responsibilities can be automated.
Perhaps the role needs greater seniority.
Perhaps the team structure needs to change.
Perhaps the salary no longer reflects the market.
Perhaps the organisation now needs a different skill set.
Simply replacing the previous employee with someone who looks similar on paper may solve the vacancy without solving the underlying problem.
Retention starts with understanding
There is no single retention strategy that works for every organisation.
The important thing is to understand what employees value, where the pressure points are and which roles are most critical to business performance.
Then act on what you learn.
Because sometimes the best recruitment strategy is not finding another person to fill the vacancy.
It is understanding why the vacancy happened in the first place.
At Bond Williams, our consultants speak to employers and candidates every day, giving us insight into changing expectations around salaries, roles, flexibility, leadership and career decisions.
If you are repeatedly recruiting for the same position, it may be time to look beyond the vacancy.
Talk to Bond Williams about your recruitment and retention challenges.



